Passchendaele Movie Review

World War I Drama hits Home

© Terry Long

Feb 4, 2009
Canadian actor Paul Gross writes, directs and stars in the Canadian war drama Passchendaele.

Telling the story of his own grandfather in the First World War, Passchendaele is a brooding romantic drama set against the turbulent years of the First World War.

Paul Gross Makes Film About Grandfather's WWI Experience

The film opens with a flashback to an incident in a bombed-out church involving Sgt. Michael Dunne, played by Gross, and several members of the Canadian Corp in Arras, France who are pinned down by a German machine gun crew. Dunne is forced to watch as the Germans mow down most of the men who are with him. He is successful in killing most of the German machine gun crew, however, he stabs a teenage boy through the forehead with his bayonet, an act that haunts him for the rest of the film. Dunne is injured by incoming artillery fire and loses consciousness to eventually awaken in a Calgary hospital. It is at this point that it is revealed that Dunne has been seeing this same sequence of events in his sleep for months and has been shipped home as a result.

Much of the film revolves around Dunne and his infatuation with nurse Sarah Mann as their lives gradually become intertwined over the first hour of the movie’s running time. Matters come to a head when Sarah’s brother David enlists, despite being asthmatic, in order to impress the father of the girl he intends to marry. Michael returns to France in order to look after him, not knowing that he has been followed by Sarah who is now deeply in love with Michael and intends to look after both of them.

The second half of the film is chiefly occupied with the Battle of Passchendaele, more commonly known as the Third Battle of Ypres; however, the historical events of the battle take a secondary role. Gross’s goal in making this movie was to tell the story of how Canada came of age. Throughout the film there are numerous references to Vimy Ridge, which was a key turning point in the war and marked Canada’s coming of age as a nation. Yet, at the same time by telling the story of his own grandfather, Gross is able to personalize the war by letting the audience into the personal lives of the people who experienced it firsthand. Dunne’s struggles with the things he has seen and been forced to do are eerily similar to the many stories that have been told by American, British and Canadian veterans of Iraq and Afghanistan.

Passchendaele Tells a Forgotten Canadian History

Additionally, even though there is little in the way of sustained battle sequences in the film, the sequences that are present are very well executed.

By making this movie Paul Gross also set out to correct a curious quirk in the collective Canadian psyche. Unlike like other countries such as the United States, Britain and more recently, Germany, Canadian film makers have shown little interest in documenting Canadian history, specifically Canada’s war time history. With no Canadian veterans of the First World War left alive, and with the survivors of the Second World War beginning to dwindle, Passchendaele is an important film in the history of Canadian cinema because it serves to preserve an important piece of Canadian history.

Overall, Passchendaele is a tense and brooding wartime drama that stretches from the scenic foothills of the Canadian Rockies to the killing fields of France and serves to remind the viewer of Canada’s baptism by fire during a time when it seemed as if the whole world had gone mad.


The copyright of the article Passchendaele Movie Review in Historical Films is owned by Terry Long. Permission to republish Passchendaele Movie Review in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.




Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo

Comments
Feb 8, 2009 10:10 PM
Guest :
Great movie and characters are well defined. Wasn't interested in seeing this movie but my son talked me into it. I was mesmerized by the reality of war and the heart breaking trauma of the character, Michael Dunne. played by Paul Gross. He was able to project so much tenderness, and loyalty to the character, and yet show tremendous courage and strength on the battlefield. I will watch this movie again. God bless the Canadians for their part in WWII. I had no idea!
Feb 17, 2009 5:48 AM
Guest :
awww the movie was soooo sad :(
buh gud at the same time ! :D

-Afg Princess
Mar 6, 2009 2:30 PM
Guest :
Excellent film, only if he had stayed within the context of the title. Major problems that I did see were:
1. The movie has him, shipped home; in truth injured soldiers were treated in England or France, the cost was too great to ship recovered,able bodied troops home, only those being discharged for wounds received this ticket home. (My own great-grandfather enlisted in 1915 and he never arrived home until 1919,as he spent over a year recuperating in England from a wound received in late 1917).
2. When David enlists and when Dunne follows him, the next frame shows "three months later". If you consider, that it took over a week to travel by rail to Halifax, and another few weeks to gather enough "bodies" to ship over. Not too mention the time to cross the Atlantic and the time spent in an English training camp, Three months is way too short. A realistic scenario would be six months at the earliest to even a year, before the main characters would see battle, notice that Dunne enlists as McCrae; he would be considered a "boot" like David.
The positives:
1. The Germans are shown attacking behind a brief yet violent curtain of steel, in order to dislodge the Canadians. This is an accurate depiction of the small unit infantry tactics that the Germans later employed. Modern stormtroop tactics.
2. The Canadians are shown as excellent riflemen and close combat specialists; this too is even more accurate. Canadian Infantry throughout previous wars and even the Afghan one, are rated at or above the level of other services such as the USMC or French Foreign Legion.
3. The enlisted NCO's/NCM's are depicted as being the true leaders, anyone who has ever served as a riflemen knows this.
-Devildog, '96-'99
Jul 3, 2009 12:49 PM
Guest :
Great movie it made a grown man cry
4 Comments